TY - JOUR
T1 - A look-back investigation of patients of an HIV-infected physician
T2 - Public health implications
AU - the Investigation Team
AU - Danila, Richard N.
AU - Macdonald, Kristine L.
AU - Moen, Michael E.
AU - Reier, Dorothy O.
AU - Letourneau, Joan C.
AU - Sheehan, Mary K.
AU - Osterholm, Michael T.
AU - Rhame, Frank S.
AU - Armstrong, Joann
AU - Bender, Mitchell E.
AU - Brandwick, Bruce
AU - Burns, Debra
AU - Clare, John
AU - Ehresmann, Kris
AU - Ferguson, Buddy
AU - Forfang, Jan
AU - Fritz, Mary Jo
AU - Gabriel, Linda
AU - Gamble, Anne
AU - Geshrick, Daniel
AU - Hedberg, Craig
AU - Higgins, Margaret
AU - Hiller, Robert
AU - Hilmer, Teresa
AU - Isensee, Jill
AU - Jacobs, Jean
AU - Jeppesen, Kim
AU - Johnson, Janice
AU - Kain, Maribel
AU - Keysser, Janet
AU - Korlath, Jack
AU - Lauer, Therese
AU - Leitheiser, Aggie
AU - Mariotti, Joe
AU - Marschall, Marlene
AU - Miller, Claudia
AU - Miller, Kathy
AU - Moore, Chris
AU - Moore, Steve
AU - Murrill, Anne
AU - Nelson, Fraser
AU - Nelson, Roy
AU - Norton, Cheryl
AU - Novotny, Gary
AU - Carroll, Andrea
AU - O'Brian,
AU - O'Brien, Mary Jo
AU - Pfeiffer, Jeanne
AU - Pierson, Lynne
AU - Ristinen, Terry
PY - 1991/11/14
Y1 - 1991/11/14
N2 - Background. Transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) to five patients receiving care from an HIV-infected dentist in Florida has recently been reported. Current data indicate that the risk of HIV transmission from health care workers to patients is extremely low. Despite this low risk, programs to notify patients of past exposure to an HIV-infected health care worker are being conducted with increasing frequency. Methods. We recently conducted an investigation of all the patients cared for by an HIV-infected family physician during a period when he had severe dermatitis caused by Mycobacterium marinum on his hands and forearms. After reviewing the patients' records, we notified 336 patients who had undergone one or more procedures (digital examination of a body cavity or vaginal delivery) placing them at potentially increased risk of HIV infection. The patients were offered tests for HIV infection and counseling. Results. Of the 336 patients, 325 (97 percent) had negative tests for HIV antibody, 3 (1 percent) refused testing, 1 (<1 percent) died of a cause unrelated to HIV infection before notification, and the HIV-antibody status of 7 (2 percent) remained unknown. The direct and indirect public health costs of this investigation were approximately $130,000. Conclusions. The results of this investigation raise important questions about the risk of HIV transmission from health care workers to patients and the usefulness of HIV look-back programs, particularly in the light of recently published recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control. We propose that before a look-back investigation is undertaken, there should be a clearly identifiable risk of transmission of the infection, substantially higher than the risk requiring limitation of an HIV-infected health care worker's practice prospectively. (N Engl J Med 1991; 325:1406–11.).
AB - Background. Transmission of the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) to five patients receiving care from an HIV-infected dentist in Florida has recently been reported. Current data indicate that the risk of HIV transmission from health care workers to patients is extremely low. Despite this low risk, programs to notify patients of past exposure to an HIV-infected health care worker are being conducted with increasing frequency. Methods. We recently conducted an investigation of all the patients cared for by an HIV-infected family physician during a period when he had severe dermatitis caused by Mycobacterium marinum on his hands and forearms. After reviewing the patients' records, we notified 336 patients who had undergone one or more procedures (digital examination of a body cavity or vaginal delivery) placing them at potentially increased risk of HIV infection. The patients were offered tests for HIV infection and counseling. Results. Of the 336 patients, 325 (97 percent) had negative tests for HIV antibody, 3 (1 percent) refused testing, 1 (<1 percent) died of a cause unrelated to HIV infection before notification, and the HIV-antibody status of 7 (2 percent) remained unknown. The direct and indirect public health costs of this investigation were approximately $130,000. Conclusions. The results of this investigation raise important questions about the risk of HIV transmission from health care workers to patients and the usefulness of HIV look-back programs, particularly in the light of recently published recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control. We propose that before a look-back investigation is undertaken, there should be a clearly identifiable risk of transmission of the infection, substantially higher than the risk requiring limitation of an HIV-infected health care worker's practice prospectively. (N Engl J Med 1991; 325:1406–11.).
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0025943529&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0025943529&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1056/NEJM199111143252003
DO - 10.1056/NEJM199111143252003
M3 - Article
C2 - 1922251
AN - SCOPUS:0025943529
SN - 0028-4793
VL - 325
SP - 1406
EP - 1411
JO - New England Journal of Medicine
JF - New England Journal of Medicine
IS - 20
ER -