Comparison of total nitrogen data from direct and Kjeldahl-based approaches in integrated data sets

Emily H. Stanley, Shirley Rojas-Salazar, Noah R. Lottig, Erin M. Schliep, Christopher T. Filstrup, Sarah M. Collins

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

1 Scopus citations

Abstract

There are multiple protocols for determining total nitrogen (TN) in water, but most can be grouped into direct approaches (TN-d) that convert N forms to nitrogen-oxides (NOx) and combined approaches (TN-c) that combine Kjeldahl N (organic N +NH3) and nitrite+nitrate (NO2+NO3-N). TN concentrations from these two approaches are routinely treated as equal in studies that use data derived from multiple sources (i.e., integrated data sets) despite the distinct chemistries of the two methods. We used two integrated data sets to determine if TN-c and TN-d results were interchangeable. Accuracy, determined as the difference between reported concentrations and the most probable value (MPV) of reference samples, was high and similar in magnitude (within 3.5–4.5% of the MPV) for both methods, although the bias was significantly smaller at low concentrations for TN-d. Detection limits and data flagged as below detection suggested greater sensitivity for TN-d for one data set, while patterns from the other data set were ambiguous. TN-c results were more variable (less precise) by many measures, although TN-d data included a small fraction of notably inaccurate results. Precision of TN-c was further compromised by propagated error, which may not be acknowledged or detectable in integrated data sets unless complete metadata are available and inspected. Finally, concurrent measures of TN-c and TN-d in lake samples were extremely similar. Overall, TN-d tended to be slightly more accurate and precise, but similarities in accuracy and the near 1 : 1 relationship for concurrent TN-d and TN-c measurements support careful use of data interchangeably in analyses of heterogeneous, integrated data sets.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)639-649
Number of pages11
JournalLimnology and Oceanography: Methods
Volume17
Issue number12
DOIs
StatePublished - Dec 1 2019

Bibliographical note

Funding Information:
Funding was provided by the National Science Foundation Macrosystems Biology Program through collaborative grants EF‐1685534 and EF‐1638550 and DBI‐1401954 to S.M.C. DEB‐1440297, NTL LTER, provided further support to E.H.S. and N.R.L.

Funding Information:
Funding was provided by the National Science Foundation Macrosystems Biology Program through collaborative grants EF-1685534 and EF-1638550 and DBI-1401954 to S.M.C. DEB-1440297, NTL LTER, provided further support to E.H.S. and N.R.L.

Publisher Copyright:
© 2019 Association for the Sciences of Limnology and Oceanography

Fingerprint

Dive into the research topics of 'Comparison of total nitrogen data from direct and Kjeldahl-based approaches in integrated data sets'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this