We have studied the effects of radiogenic heat sources Qm and heat flux from the deep mantle q∞ on the multivalued relation between shear stress at the base of the lithosphere τ and plate velocity u0. If there are sufficient heat sources in the asthenosphere or if considerable heat flows up from the deep mantle, τ increases with u0; such states are called subcritical. However, if neither of these conditions exist then τ decreases with u0; such states are called supercritical. The uncertainties in both Qm and q∞ preclude any inference about the τ vs. u0 relation for the earth's lithosphere. We have also examined whether shear heating instability, associated with the strong temperature dependence of mantle viscosity, can occur in these asthenospheric shear flows. Based on a linear, one-dimensional analysis with coupled temperature and horizontal velocity perturbations, we find that all flows are stable for a constant surface velocity boundary condition while supercritical flows are unstable if basal shear stress is fixed.
Bibliographical noteFunding Information:
We would like to thank Fritz Busse, Lute Fleitout and Jay Melosh for stimulating comments on this subject. This work was supported by the Earth Sciences Section, National Science Foundation, NSF Grant EAR-77-15198 and by intramural computing funds from the University of California.