TY - JOUR
T1 - The elusive structure of CrCl2 - A combined computational and gas-phase electron-diffraction study
AU - Vest, Brian
AU - Varga, Zoltán
AU - Hargittai, Magdolna
AU - Hermann, Andreas
AU - Schwerdtfeger, Peter
PY - 2008/6/9
Y1 - 2008/6/9
N2 - Chromium dichloride poses a challenge to the structural chemist. Its different forms of aggregation and association display all well-known structural distortions induced by vibronic interactions. The monomeric molecule has a Renner-Teller distorted bent geometry, the crystal exhibits strong Jahn-Teller distortion, and the oligomers have slightly distorted four-membered-ring structures due to the pseudo-Jahn-Teller effect. In this paper we report on the low-energy structures of the monomer and its clusters, Cr2Cl 4, Cr3Cl6, and Cr4Cl8, from unrestricted Kohn-Sham (broken-symmetry) density functional calculations. CrCl2 was also investigated at higher level, including coupled-cluster and state-average CASSCF computations. The global minima of the gas-phase clusters consist of two-dimensional, antiferromagnetically coupled chains of CrCl2 units forming four-membered, doubly bridged Cr 2Cl2 rings, closely resembling the solid-state structure of α-CrCl2. Each Cr atom in these chains has spin quantum number S = 2. This suggests that the CrCl2 nucleation starts very early on the structural chain motif found in the solid. There is only a very small change in energy from the antiferromagnetically to the ferromagnetically coupled Cr atoms, which indicates little spin-coupling between the metal centers. There is an approximately constant change in energy, about 50 kcal mol-1, with every new CrCl2 unit during cluster formation. Information about the structure of these clusters was used in the re-analysis of high-temperature electron-diffraction data. The vapor at 1170K contained about 77% monomeric molecules, 19% dimers, and a small amount of trimers. Monomeric CrCl2 was found to be bent with a bond angle of 149(10)°, in good agreement with our computations, which resulted in a Renner-Teller distortion of the lowest-energy 5∏g electronic state into the bent 5B2 ground state. The vibrational spectrum of chromium dichloride is discussed and the thermodynamics of cluster formation from 1000-2000 K is examined.
AB - Chromium dichloride poses a challenge to the structural chemist. Its different forms of aggregation and association display all well-known structural distortions induced by vibronic interactions. The monomeric molecule has a Renner-Teller distorted bent geometry, the crystal exhibits strong Jahn-Teller distortion, and the oligomers have slightly distorted four-membered-ring structures due to the pseudo-Jahn-Teller effect. In this paper we report on the low-energy structures of the monomer and its clusters, Cr2Cl 4, Cr3Cl6, and Cr4Cl8, from unrestricted Kohn-Sham (broken-symmetry) density functional calculations. CrCl2 was also investigated at higher level, including coupled-cluster and state-average CASSCF computations. The global minima of the gas-phase clusters consist of two-dimensional, antiferromagnetically coupled chains of CrCl2 units forming four-membered, doubly bridged Cr 2Cl2 rings, closely resembling the solid-state structure of α-CrCl2. Each Cr atom in these chains has spin quantum number S = 2. This suggests that the CrCl2 nucleation starts very early on the structural chain motif found in the solid. There is only a very small change in energy from the antiferromagnetically to the ferromagnetically coupled Cr atoms, which indicates little spin-coupling between the metal centers. There is an approximately constant change in energy, about 50 kcal mol-1, with every new CrCl2 unit during cluster formation. Information about the structure of these clusters was used in the re-analysis of high-temperature electron-diffraction data. The vapor at 1170K contained about 77% monomeric molecules, 19% dimers, and a small amount of trimers. Monomeric CrCl2 was found to be bent with a bond angle of 149(10)°, in good agreement with our computations, which resulted in a Renner-Teller distortion of the lowest-energy 5∏g electronic state into the bent 5B2 ground state. The vibrational spectrum of chromium dichloride is discussed and the thermodynamics of cluster formation from 1000-2000 K is examined.
KW - Chromium dichloride
KW - Density functional calculations
KW - Electron diffraction
KW - Nucleation
KW - Renner-Teller effect
KW - Structure elucidation
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=53849146400&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=53849146400&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1002/chem.200800331
DO - 10.1002/chem.200800331
M3 - Article
C2 - 18491335
AN - SCOPUS:53849146400
SN - 0947-6539
VL - 14
SP - 5130
EP - 5143
JO - Chemistry - A European Journal
JF - Chemistry - A European Journal
IS - 17
ER -